Showing posts with label shelf. Show all posts
Showing posts with label shelf. Show all posts

Wednesday, October 1, 2008

The utilization constant

The single factor that has the most influence on a model railroad is the space you have available to build it in. the nature of the space has quite a bit of influence, but the size is always dominant. When you have the luxury of building a dedicated, special purpose building to house your layout, the problem manifests itself in reverse. While size is still a strong determinant, and nobody has infinite money or buildable land, you can choose to make the building as big as you need it to be to create the layout you want. You have to ask yourself, “How much layout do I want?” and believe me, you’d better have a good answer.

I started my planning with a rough guesstimate that 2000 square feet would work for me. After several design sketches, I ended up expanding that number to about 2500 square feet. As I played with different track arrangements, it became clear to me that I was faced with several choices that modelers with a predetermined layout room are not.

For one thing, aisles weren’t something that I would squeeze into the space left over, but they were something whose width I could determine in advance and then design the track around them.

The next thing I realized is that the depth of any scene on a sincere shelf layout would always average out to about 24 inches. In towns and industrial areas where trackage is dense, it might widen out to as much as 36 inches, but any more than that would require special benchwork to provide access. The shelf would rarely get narrower than 12 inches, because any less than that would provide too little room for scenery.

Any given portion of the layout room would thus always have a fairly regular cross section in between the two containing walls or backdrops. There would be a central aisle with a shelf on either side. I decided early on that a four foot minimum width aisle would be my design target.
Furthermore, it appears that this model yields a relatively constant ratio of room area to model area. Of course this ratio will vary depending on the standards you choose. But if you pick one standard and stick to it, the ratio remains constant. This means that you can work backwards from your layout size goal to determine the square footage required to build it.


In my 50’ by 50’ room, if I lay the track on a two-foot-wide shelf all around the walls, I can have only 200 linear feet of track. I can calculate the ratio of track to room size by dividing the linear track length by the square footage of the room, or 200 divided by 2500, which equals 0.08, an extremely low proportion. But it is low because all of the infield space is wasted, and I can get the same length of linear track in a much smaller room, as long as it is no wider than one basic cross section. Such a long and narrow room would be 8’ by 92’, or 736 square feet, and it will still give me 200 linear feet of model railroad track. Now if I divide 200 by 736 I get a ratio of track length to room area of approximately 0.27, a little better than one in four.
But shelves don’t only have to follow walls, and if I have a square room they can extend on a peninsula into the middle exploit the space available there. The peninsula is actually two shelves back to back; one for the track headed into the center and one for the track headed back out. The two shelves are separated by a very thin, common wall, appropriately called a view block. In practice, a view block in a layout this big might be 4 or 6 inches thick, but I will ignore that here for the sake of clarity. Using my 50’ by 50’, 2500 square foot room, we add a single, four-foot-wide, two-sided peninsula extending into the center. While maintaining our four foot wide aisles, the peninsula spirals into the center of the room, utilizing the available space as efficiently as possible. The very end of the peninsula is called a “blob” (yes, “blob” is a very precise term of art in the modeling community), where it widens out to allow the track to turn back on itself.

In this plan, the total trackage available is about 670 linear feet. If you divide 670 linear feet of track by 2500 square feet of area, you get 0.268, which rounds up to, surprise, 0.27, the exact same ratio we discovered in our first, minimal example.

It appears that we have discovered a constant. Because this constant ratio measures the portion of the room’s area that is utilized for layout compared to the portion that isn’t, I’ll call it the “utilization constant.”

This utilization constant of approximately 0.27 can be applied to any big railroad room (again assuming you use two foot shelves and four foot aisles). For example, if you have 1200 square feet to build your railroad in, you can know before hand that the optimal amount of main line length you can expect is 324 linear feet, if your room’s dimensions are optimal for the shelf depth and aisle width.

Notice that there is very little wasted space on this plan. Except for the single blob, the shelves are never more than 24 inches deep and the aisles are never less than 48 inches wide. If the room were widened by, say, four feet, the added space could not be used as efficiently. That’s because there wouldn’t be enough room to add an entire new leg of the peninsula. For that, we’d need at least four feet for the peninsula and four more feet for the additional aisle. That means that using a two-foot shelf and four-foot aisle, we should only add space in increments of eight feet; no more and no less.

Of course, the ratio will increase if I use, say, 12 inch deep shelves. The ratio will increase dramatically if I narrow down the aisle width, as that is where the lion’s share of the area goes. For smaller layouts, reducing the aisle width is feasible for the simple reason that smaller layouts have fewer, shorter aisles in absolute terms, and smaller layouts are operated with far fewer people, so the congestion is far less. On the other hand, for larger layouts, generous aisle widths are extremely important.

Even if you have a four foot minimum aisle width, on a large layout with a full crew, there is no place within the layout proper to gather everyone together for a briefing or group photo. A separate crew lounge for a layout this big should be considered non-optional, but it would still be nice to have at least one really wide spot in the layout room where everyone can gather.

Just for the sake of completeness, let’s look at the ratio if we use aisles that are 36 inches wide. Here’s our simple 200 linear foot layout: It requires only seven feet of width (2 x 2’ for the shelves plus 3’ for the aisle) so the area is 651 square feet. Dividing 200 by 651 yields approximately 0.31. on a full 2500 square foot room, this new ratio holds constant just as before. With only 36 inch wide aisles, this new plan yields another lap of the spiral, so the linear distance increases to 784’ in the same area. Dividing 784 by 2500 yields 0.31, which we can see is now our 36 inch wide aisle constant.

Going back to the 0.27 utilization ratio for my minimum of four foot wide aisles, I can now see what it would take to model the entire 140 mile long NKP Middle Division. If I chose an overall selective compression ratio of one to ten, it would take 850 linear feet of mainline (140 x 60.5’ = 847’). Dividing 850 by 0.27 equals 3148 square feet. This means that it would take a minimum of about 3150 square feet to model the Middle Division in HO using a single-deck, sincere shelf, with four foot wide aisles.

While these two utilization constant examples are interesting, they are based on single deck layouts. For an operations oriented layout, multi-decking is generally considered a worthwhile tradeoff for greater linear track distance. In my next posting, I’ll tackle multi-deck layouts.

Monday, September 22, 2008

Planning for a Big Space

I’m modeling the Nickel Plate Railroad as it was in 1949. Actually, I’m modeling just one portion, called a division, of just one section, called a district, of the Nickel Plate. My district was the former Lake Erie & Western Railroad, acquired by the NKP in 1926, and thenceforth designated the Lake Erie & Western District. The division I’m modeling is called the Middle Division. It’s not exactly the same as the Middle Division of the old LE&W, because at the time of the acquisition the division boundaries of the LE&W were jiggered somewhat to fit into the existing division structure of the NKP, but the name stayed. The Middle Division runs eastward from Frankfort, Indiana, to Lima, Ohio, a distance of about 140 miles.

I model in HO scale, which is a ratio of 1 to 87. In HO scale an average person would stand about ½ inch tall. That means that one mile of track in HO is 5280 (the number of feet in a mile) divided by 87 or 60.7 feet. To model just the Middle Division, I’d need 8,500 linear feet of track!

Model railroaders use a concept they call “selective compression,” by which they can save lots of space yet still capture the essence of a thing in a model. Basically, you model the visually unique and operationally significant parts of things, while severely truncating or eliminating portions that are either not operationally significant or visually redundant.

For example, a huge meat packing plant might be six stories high and 200 feet square, served by 6 tracks. A good model of it could be four stories high and 50 by 100 feet, served by three tracks. The spirit of the industry is retained while the footprint is dramatically reduced.

The place where selective compression is practiced more than anywhere else is along the mainline. For example, the tangent (straight) track between two towns is cut from 15 miles to a fraction of one mile. The trackage in the towns themselves would also be selectively compressed, but typically by a much smaller amount. In other words, from a modeler’s point of view, the scenery and trackage within the town is of much more interest than the scenery and trackage between the towns.

I’ve been planning to fit my model of the Middle Division into a room approximately 50’ by 50’, or 2500 square feet. By any model railroad standard that is a room of Brobdingnagian proportions. I’ve never even seen a home layout that big anywhere. But even with that generous amount of room, I’ll be lucky to fit one tenth of it in!

Years ago, model railroads were of for the most part imaginary railroads constructed on enormous tabletops and the track looped over, under, around, and through. Trains of every type and description swarmed over the landscape while the proprietor sat at a large electrical control console and sent the trains where he desired. An observer was hard pressed to know where a train would emerge once it entered one of the many tunnels visible. This style of layout is seriously out of date, and has been largely discredited, and is now referred to as “spaghetti bowl” design.

In recent years modelers have placed far more emphasis on duplicating actual prototype railroads and the actual landscape they traverse. What’s more, many modelers, me included, are focused particularly on duplicating the same operating practices the prototype followed with as much fidelity as possible. In other words, we build a model of a specific railroad, and then we operate it like the specific railroad did. Interestingly, operations can be selectively compressed just like scenery or trackage.

Contemporary layout design utilizes a couple of principles that have sufficiently demonstrated their superiority for realism, construction simplicity, and operational verisimilitude. In particular, layouts are built as relatively shallow shelves, and the mainline of the track only passes through each shelf once. Some people call this type of layout a “sincere shelf.” Of course, there are myriad exceptions and variations to these principles, but I’ll avoid them for clarity.

The primary advantage of the sincere shelf is that an operator can walk along with his train, more easily imagining that he is inside the locomotive because the limits to what he can physically see are very similar to what an engineer inside the locomotive’s cab could see. The single track running through a narrow strip of landscape is the moral equivalent of what the real engineer is aware of as he proceeds down the right of way.

Whatever ultimate size and shape my model railroad will be, it will be composed mostly of a very long sincere shelf. It will likely be wrapped around itself in some spiral fashion in order to make the best use of the space. While real railroads go from one point to another in basically a straight line, few of us have model railroad rooms that are eight feet wide and 1000 feet long.

I have learned much about model railroad planning as a result of the many, many (some would claim too many) track designs I have made. Most model railroads occupy only a couple hundred square feet of space, and the lessons such layouts teach us are commonly known. Because I am planning to build a much, much larger model layout, I’m encountering some lesser known problems and opportunities. It is my intention to record those lessons in this blog, so stay tuned.